Originally posted by Midhun
Hi, I have a question on calculating Terminal Value when the Discount rate is lesser than Long term growth rate.Can we still use DCF for such cases or should be use some other valuation model ? |
Discount rate (WACC) cannot be lesser than terminal growth rate practically... IN MY PERSONAL OPINION!
Because... WACC is weighted average cost of capital i.e. cost of debt and cost equities weighed average!
Now, if you think about cost of debt - it is the rate at which the company will be able to borrow money in future... i.e. the interest rate they pay will have to be higher than the long term inflation expected in the country (10 yr govt. bond yeild)...
hence, cost of debt is always > 10 yr govt bond yield
Similarly, Cost of equity is... risk free rate (Rf) + beta (equity risk premium.i.e Rm-Rf).... Rf is generally the 10 yr govt bond yield.... hence adding the multiple of Beta and ERP we will always get a higher value than Rf which is the 10yr govt bond yield...
even if you think about it logically... cost of equity is the returns expected by the equity holders of the company... this expected return on equity holding will always be higher than any debt holding generally.
hence, cost of equity also is always > 10 yr govt bond yield
And the discount rate (WACC) which is sum of both above....will be much higher than the 10yr govt bond yield....i.e. for india 7.8% approx is the 10 yr govt bond yield... discount rate for any company in india will be higher than 7.8%
Discount rate is always > 10 yr govt bond yield
Terminal growth rate is the growth rate at which company is expected to grow perpetually.... now a company cannot grow higher than the economy for a perpetual period of time... it has to grow at the economy growth rate or less... now if we consider india... it is growing at 8.5-9.0 % ... but is this growth sustainable perpetually....??
no country can grow at this rate forever! (may be for a few decades but not perpetually)... the country will reach a mature stage where it will only grow by about 4-5 %...
thus Terminal growth rate cannot be higher than 5%
To sum up, Terminal growth rate cannot be higher than 5% and Discount rate cannot be lower than 7.8% ... thus according to me... discount rate cannot be lesser than long term terminal growth rate...
This is my personal understanding and opinion which could be wrong....... kindly share any other views!