Active TopicsActive Topics  Display List of Forum MembersMemberlist  CalendarCalendar  Search The ForumSearch  HelpHelp
  RegisterRegister  LoginLogin

Fundamental
 The Equity Desk Forum :Market Strategies :Fundamental
Message Icon Topic: Transcripts for TED Meet 4 – MumbaiPune Chapter Post Reply Post New Topic
Page  of 12 Next >>
Author Message
Shadofax
Senior Member
Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: 27/Nov/2007
Location: India
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 193
Quote Shadofax Replybullet Topic: Transcripts for TED Meet 4 – MumbaiPune Chapter
    Posted: 18/Aug/2010 at 1:58pm
Transcripts for TED Meet 4 – MumbaiPune Chapter

 

Post 1 

Q: What is risk?

Basant:

        Over a period of time risk comes from doing what you don’t know.

        If you are buying strong stable consumer oriented companies, you will get your money back. It may take a some time but the chance of permanent capital destruction as Buffett says is minimal..

        I don’t believe in mindless diversification. Something like, “I don’t want to own 3 stocks but I want to own 30. So I will buy 27 with little or no information against only 3 in which I have good information better buy the 3 and put your heart and soul into it.”

        Risk is buying 27 unknown names rather than buying 3 known names.

        With a 5 to 10 stock portfolio I can’t buy any stock that may be cheap. Even though they may be very cheap you have to leave it alone. With a few stocks one has to think exclusively in terms of return of capital rather then return on capital

        Now let’s say you have a 15 stock portfolio. Maybe you can then take a 2% bet on those cheap stocks. But with a “2% exposure majaa nahi aayega and with 20% exposure in them neend nahi aayegee”

Q: Your experience with investing? How did you start?

Basant:

.

        I wanted to invest full time. I read Jim Rogers where he said he wanted to retire at 37. So I said even I will. And 2010, I am 37.

        In 2000, my family business went bust due to political reasons. We lost all the money and I had to relocate to Calcutta. I did not  know what to do because we were losing money fighting court cases with the J&K government I thought the best way to earn more money is to buy DSQ and GTL. because the gains would have been faster, those stocks went up 10 times between 1999 and 2000 and then fell 99%.

        Then I started teaching because I thought this will ensure independence as well as earn money to invest. Got introduced to One up on Wall Street and Warren Buffett and tried understanding their philosophy, meanwhile made quick money buying the beaten down SSIs and the HCL Techs post the WTC crash, and a quick multibagger in E-Serve Mphasis, Mastek and built up some base capital. I borrowed and surrendered all my LIC policies and fortunately the cheques came in the week after the WTC went down.

 

In 2003 came the real big one, a student told me about Pantaloon and I had read One up on Wall Street and all I thought was a 100 bagger I bought it really early and then leveraged on them (margin funding) and bought more of it in an infinite loop bought lots of Trent and then TV 18. All these stocks went up and so did the leverage and my position. It was all a matter of chance. I did not  do anything. Pantaloon did it. I used to see NASDAQ every night . “ke  jyaada na gir jaaye varna margin calls trigger ho jaayenge”

 

Also I had nothing to lose. But given a chance I will not be able to do the same thing again.

When people say, I don’t have anything to lose, they generally keep on loosing. It was a kind of a good solid random event that happened with me.

 

If you have a steady flow of income you are one of the most fortunate people on earth because you can invest every month. If the amount of money that you are putting in the market is manifold your monthly income, only then it makes sense to become a full time investor. Else it might not be worth it

 

Try and get a job where you have to work for 8/9 hours and not 16 hours. I strongly suggest that don’t leave a job unless you have a big amount at hand. Before you become a full time investor, you should have 50 times your annual expense as surplus.



Edited by basant - 01/Sep/2011 at 8:33pm
$
IP IP Logged
Shadofax
Senior Member
Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: 27/Nov/2007
Location: India
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 193
Quote Shadofax Replybullet Posted: 18/Aug/2010 at 2:00pm

Q. Major learning of 2008

1.        Stocks can go lower than you think. Look at Voltas with a 20% increase in earnings it fell 90%!

2.        I would buy solid moderate growth companies unless I have a chance to make a 10 to 20 bagger

3.        High ROCE generates cash. After a few years (2-5 years ) this excess cash gives good yield protection and ensures that the price comes back on the basis of the yield but one has to check for dividend growth also which is an offshoot of company growth. Buying companies that are not growing is not the solution. The idea is to buy companies that are increasing their payouts with free cash.

4.        If you want 20% CAGR from Infra stocks ... I would say buy the stable Consumer names

5.        Between a 20% of a stable consumer company like Nestle and a 30% in  Voltas, I would go with the former.

6.        If I bet on the infra and the cyclical sector I would need 40%- 45% CAGR otherwise I am not interested

7.        For an investor there are 2 ways of making money in markets. One is when stocks go up and the other is when they do not go down much. Buy those companies which tend to fall less when the market falls. Example this time if you would have noticed some stocks don’t fall with markets (relatively).Hawkins, Page, Zydus, Titan etc. So when others fall big and these don’t fall. I can encash from them and put into those that have fallen huge.

8.        Obviously fundamentals should be good.

9.        After a big decrease in price, the stock has to stay there for sometime (10 -30 days) to show that it is a bottom. Stock markets peak only in 1-2-3 days. But when it comes down it generally stays for a sometime. Bottoms are created in months. I don’t have any logic to support this. Just my experience and history. That is why it is easier to buy at the bottoms and so tough to sell at the top.

10.    I also look at volumes when the price rises or falls.

11.    But initial research comes from company and business model analysis. (This is the first step)

Q. Should there be a index based investing or not?

Basant: Not in India. Because it is a MCAP weighted and not PRICE weighted index. 

Q. Importance of Macro-economic environment.

 

Basant: As Peter Lynch says, I spend just 13 minutes in 1 year on Macroeconomic environment studies.. GDP, IIP, Inflation, etc are all one year events and dependent on the base that they have created in the previous year. Business models do not change on year to year that is why I like focusing on the latter rather then the former. I give zero importance to broad macro trends and 100% weightage to the companies that I own. I have stopped watching Business Channels (except for about 30 – 45  minutes at night) do not get get pink papers at home. These things have made life easier for me. Sometimes I feel that investing does not need all the information that we get. As investors we give equal importance to all the information whereas the weightages should vary quite drastically so one has to choose the information he feels is relevant and skip the others.

Q. Why is past performance important?

 

Past trend is very important. You don’t have companies with historic sales growth of 10%  suddenly growing at 40%. This is a rare event. Very rare. For this some external change has to happen. A friend says that a Leopard does not become a Giraffe overnight or the other way round it is against the rule of nature and so the past trend is important more then the absolute figures.

 

Though Peter Lynch said that we can’t drive the car looking at the rear view mirror, but that doesn’t mean you don’t look back. Sometimes we have to see who is coming from behind.

 

Generally good past record has a good possibility of good future record. Unless it is a cyclical.

Q. Is every company not a cyclical?

Basant: A non-cyclical is something which uses  commodity (people or material) as an input and sells its product with pricing power – Brand or quality assurance.

A raw material as a commodity and brand as output is not a cyclical. When a raw material is cyclical it doesn’t matter. It is the output (finished product) that matters.



Edited by basant - 18/Aug/2010 at 7:55pm
$
IP IP Logged
Shadofax
Senior Member
Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: 27/Nov/2007
Location: India
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 193
Quote Shadofax Replybullet Posted: 18/Aug/2010 at 2:01pm
Post 3
 
Q. Should we look at index while investing in the company?

Basant: No. If your company is going to grow at of 40% why will you not buy the stock?

But if you are not checking on behavioural finance, it would be difficult to make big big return.

Read the book: Why smart people make big money mistakes.The author discusses a host of biases and they all apply to investing.

Q. Current Sector bets?

Basant: Consumer Companies with dominant positions, efficiently using capital  and relatively small market caps compared to the scale of opportunity.

Q. Basantjee stressed a lot on high growth stocks. Why should anyone not invest in new stocks ideas for a 20% 25% CAGR returns?

You should only find those gems in the dust if the expected return is 35% or above. Else I would buy Nestle, Gruh, HDFC Bank, Marico, Dabur etc. I mean I won’t risk much for earning just 20-25%. Why to re-invent the wheel?

If you are buying a TITAN you have to pay more. Problem is 14 PE doesn’t have growth. But 40 PE is expensive. But when was life so simple?. Think about it, we are blessed to be in a country where one can ignore the 20% growers as boring companies!

Some other discussion:

So if you are in consumer stocks it becomes a little easy to make this call.

Also PE re-rating happens only when there is growth re-rating

Some Other insights:

        First you have to be an optimist

        Pessimist will generally tend to only look at Dividend yields.

        No problem in being an optimist, obviously you will make mistakes. But you will learn also.At the end the gains will overwhelm the losses because theoretically when you buy a stock the maximum you can lose is 100% and the maximum you can gain is infinity.

 

Q. What kind of business should do well over a long term?

1. Sector leaders

2. High Entry Barriers

3. Less Capex

4. Scalable

5. High Return on Capital

(Above points is not in particular order)

Q. Why has anyone not been able to make 30% CAGR for 30 years?

Basant:

My personal experience of reading and markets is that people don’t change themselves with the market so if a person has a partcular style he is focused on that style for ever whereas the opportunity relating to his style might have disappeared. Many bought MNC companies e.g. HUL and then could not make any other meaningful bets.

 

There was a rapid fire round for Basant:

1.        Corporate Governance or Performance? Basant: Corp governance

2.        Tatas, Birlas, Ambanis, Mahindras? Basant: None

3.        Yes bank, HDFC Bank, Axis? Basant: HDFC Bank

4.        5 times in 5 years or 10 times in 10 years? Basant: 5 times in 5 years

5.        Market share or Market Price? Basant: Market share

6.        Management preference who meets with analysts or not? Basant:  Management which doesn’t meet anyone.

7.        Simple business with ordinary management or complex management? Basant: Simple business with good management

8.        High ROE or high growth? Basant: ROE (but doesn’t work all the time)

9.        Great innovators or great followers? Basant: Followers because that makes for simple businesses.

!! Okay that’s the end !!

<< Proof reading was done by Basantjee>>

Guys, this is what I could come up with in terms of transcripts. This was a little tiring but I am sure this will help us all learn a lot. It is also fun to read. I have taken almost all the major parts that were discussed.

There were a few sectors related question but bottom line from Basant was that he was bullish on Consumer Related companies. There were only a few stock related questions.



Edited by basant - 18/Aug/2010 at 7:58pm
$
IP IP Logged
shivkumar
Senior Member
Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: 02/Oct/2007
Location: India
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 2037
Quote shivkumar Replybullet Posted: 18/Aug/2010 at 2:13pm
quite comprehensive and covered all the important points.
IP IP Logged
Gurdial
Senior Member
Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: 29/Apr/2010
Location: India
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 147
Quote Gurdial Replybullet Posted: 18/Aug/2010 at 2:30pm
Pretty insightful. I have lot to learn from Basant ji.

IP IP Logged
prabhakarkudva
Senior Member
Senior Member


Joined: 16/Jan/2008
Location: India
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 1624
Quote prabhakarkudva Replybullet Posted: 18/Aug/2010 at 2:35pm
Great effort. Really appreciate the work you've put in.
Take your chances and keep them in a box until a quieter time.
IP IP Logged
karn
Senior Member
Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: 05/Apr/2010
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 798
Quote karn Replybullet Posted: 18/Aug/2010 at 2:38pm
Thanks for your efforts. Wonderful
“Invert, always invert.”
IP IP Logged
vijaygawde
Senior Member
Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: 21/Mar/2008
Location: India
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 851
Quote vijaygawde Replybullet Posted: 18/Aug/2010 at 2:40pm
Neat Job Clap
Thank you very much !!
Diversification is protection against ignorance, it makes little sense for those who know what they’re doing.
IP IP Logged
Page  of 12 Next >>
Post Reply Post New Topic
Printable version Printable version

Forum Jump
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot create polls in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum



This page was generated in 0.142 seconds.
Bookmark this Page